Tag Archive: anna travis


Book Review: Red Dahlia


Author: Lynda La Plante
Title: The Red Dahlia
Genre: Crime
ISBN: 0743257073
‘A young girl is found dumped on the banks of the Thames. Horrifically mutilated and drained of blood, her death is an ominous mirror image of an unsolved 1940s case in Los Angeles known as The Black Dahlia. ‘


I’m missing something. I must be. This is the second book by La Plante I have read and I am less than wowed. Part of me screams ‘what right do you have?!’ but the rest of me says; ‘plenty! I’m a reader as well as a writer. I can dip my feet into both sides of the pool.’ Then I get totally side tracked and think about a t-shirt I want from the OOTS shop saying ‘I’m true neutral; I go both ways,’ but that’s another story.

Yawn. This book has fell into the same holes that Silent Scream did, but worse. This is earlier than that one, so I can see where La Plante has improved going forward. But it still not enough to stop me tutting. I’m reading the books out of sequence, but I’m fortunate enough that this makes no difference to how I feel about the stories/writing except to make the relationship between Anna Travis and James Langton hop around like a cat on a hot tin roof. But it does that anyway. o.O

Langton is actually a fantastic character in that he has earned my deepest, deepest hate. Lol. I don’t know enough about him (maybe his first appearance to the series might have put me in a different mind set), but he is the typical workaholic chauvinist with a seriously irritating Hamlet complex. Any woman out there could (and would) scream that he is not good enough for the intelligent, undervalued Anna (sorry, is my sarcasm too loud for you? -_-). The problem is, I don’t have a similar feeling about Anna; not that I don’t dislike her, but that I don’t feel anything for her. Nothing at all.

That is the big failing for me.

This marks my second meeting with Anna Travis the amazing detective but she is still bland, lifeless and just a little bit silly in my eyes (seriously; what the hell was she thinking with that reporter?!). Coupled with that thirty-forty pages down the line I may be able to get off the wild ride at the next stop (yes, back to my train analogy from Silent Scream). It slow. Far too slow in paces and in others it leaps along so fast that I can’t keep up. Particularly the end where the police are starting to narrow the net on their killer’s whereabouts. Why oh why oh why does it take them so long to pin this guy when they know damn well its him from about half way through? It just makes it boring. :(

But I’m not yet completely put off. This book marks one of La Plante’s earlier novels before she really got her teeth into what she is capable of. There is plenty of potential to go a long way with the series, so I will make a point of picking up another of her books when next I see one.
Honest guv.

Book Review: Silent Scream


Author: Lynda La Plante
Title: Silent Scream
Genre: Crime
ISBN: 1847396461
‘Hot young British film star Amanda Delany had the world at her feet. She’d had a string of affairs with famous actors, making perfect fodder for the tabloids. Then came a commission to write a tell-all memoir. When Amanda is found brutally murdered, DCI James Langton’s enquiry discovers the sad truth behind her successful facade. Addicted to drugs and starvation diets, she’d almost died from a botched abortion. Meanwhile, DI Anna Travis is up for promotion, but Langton is blocking her, accusing her of professional misconduct. This latest case could make or break Anna’s career. ‘


Poor, poor little Amanda Delany.

La Plante seems to enjoy bumping off sad, young women and having the police force come to the (delayed) rescue.  Maybe its because these books aren’t my usual reading choice; police procedural crime novels are a far step away from vamp-fic and high fantasy.  However I still can’t the shake the feeling that in picking up this book, I got onto a train and made all the stops sign posted on the poster above the doors:
-Crime committed
-Police begin hunting
-Higher authority steps in to ‘take control’
-Potential suspects lie through their teeth and subsequently get caught out
-Police still have no clue
-Anna and Langton have their almost love affair
-Anna finds that one teeny weeny piece of info that no one else could find which opens up the case
-Suspects are rounded up
-Anna’s brainy-brainy-brain saves the day

By the time the final suspect is brought in you know damn well that he is the murder and you’re waiting for the remaining forty pages to pass so you can hear him confess.  Suspense is held and deliciously tense, until a point where the novel turns from being investigative to explanatory.

It just doesn’t quite hit the spot for me.

There is another of these books floating around – a colleague at work has it – and we’re going to do a swap when she’s done.  I’ll write up another review then and see how I feel; maybe the next book will go some way towards making me change my mind.

%d bloggers like this: